Josheli
  • Home
  • Blog
    • Knob
    • Running
    • Soccer
    • Technology
  • About
Knob , Soccer

US Soccer is a shit show and makes me sad

by dv November 17, 2017 No Comments

So let’s recap:

  • Men’s national team failed to qualify the 2018 World Cup.
  • The U23 Men’s team has failed to qualify for the last two Olympics.
  • Columbus Crew is possibly moving to Austin/holding Columbus hostage for a new stadium.
  • NASL is suing USSF for denying the NASL Division 2 sanctioning.
  • Youth clubs are suing USSF for not paying FIFA-mandated solidarity and training compensation fees.
  • Pyramid? What Pyramid? This year there were two Division 2 leagues and zero Division 3 leagues. Next year there will be either 1 or 2 Division Two leagues and 0, 1 or 2 Division 3 leagues.
  • MLS has 3 defunct teams. USL has at least 10. Latest incarnation of NASL has at least 4.
  • MLS TV ratings are abysmal and not getting better, despite claims to contrary. [1]
  • MLS attendance is flat, despite claims to contrary. [2]
  • The entity that regulates MLS (the USSF) is actually a business parter with MLS (through SUM). Don Garber, commissioner of MLS, is on the USSF board, which regulates MLS. What?
  • USSF gave USL 30 days to be in compliance with D2 standards. That “deadline” passed more than a month ago.
  • MLS claims all franchises must have a soccer-specific stadium. NYFC will play in Yankee Stadium indefinitely. Atlanta plays in a football stadium. Etc.
  • USL claims all franchises will a soccer-specific stadium. Atlanta and Memphis were announced as new franchises … playing in baseball stadiums (not to mention the many current franchises not playing in soccer-specific stadiums).
  • Three clubs have jumped from USL to NASL. Two clubs have moved to MLS. Half-a-dozen clubs have folded. There is no stability.
  • The San Francisco Deltas won the NASL championship but are set to fold. Nashville has never had a team and is set to play in MLS.
  • In 2006 Don Garber said MLS wanted to expand to Rochester. In 2017 Rochester is set to fold unless $1.3 million can be found in the next few weeks.
  • For many years ECNL was the top girls youth league. US Soccer recently chose to usurp that league’s position by establishing their own “top league for girls,” and a cold war rages.
  • Is MLS a ponzi scheme?

This is not an exhaustive list, but it is exhausting. As you can see, no level of soccer in the country is immune to infighting, half-truths, struggles, corruption. From youth to pro, US soccer is unstable and under-performing. And it’s only because I care that I focus on all of the negative in soccer. Admittedly, some of the items in this list could be debated and/or removed, or seen in a different light, but the illustration holds that there is a lot to be worked on in US Soccer. We could be a world power if we unified our pyramid all the way down to the youth level, and it makes me sad that we aren’t.

[1] 2017 saw a 4% uptick in MLS TV ratings, but looking closer, ESPN was down, while FOX and Univision were up. Also, Atlanta and Minnesota came on as expansion franchises, accounting for the 4% growth (basically the only one watching MLS are people in MLS cities). Finally, ratings weren’t good in the first place, so lipstick on a pig.
[2] If you look at 2015 to 2016 change, 11 of the 20 MLS team attendance averages fell or remained flat. The 2017 numbers (up only 1.8%) are inflated by Atlanta.

Related Content:

  • Training Compensation for Youth Clubs by Dv February 18, 2015 Here's an interesting article discussing (the lack of) training compensation for USA youth clubs. If you're not familiar, the basic…
  • Growing the Game ... or Unleashing It? by Dv March 16, 2015 I posted this as a comment on another MLS-as-savior article, but thought it would be worthy of it's own home...…
  • Correlation is not Causation by Dv February 19, 2015 Don Garber, 2010: "we will drive the increased quality and success of the Canadian national team." Canada Soccer, 2014: "an…
  • Is it OK to Club-Hop? by Dv April 29, 2014 Tryout season is nearly upon us. As in other years, I've heard parents talking on the sideline about switching clubs.…
  • Racing through by Dv April 25, 2010 I'd like to polish the Knob more often, hopefully this is a start. I still have goals, and I thought…
It's only fair to share...Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on email
Email
  • Previous Still running? Still running.8 years ago
  • Next Simple Google Photos: A WordPress Plugin8 years ago

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Posts

  • Josheli, What Happened? (55,644)
  • Stupidly Simple, Static, Startpage for Self-hosted Services (31,500)
  • Running a Plex Media Server on an Old Laptop (26,651)
  • Three Saturdays (25,280)
  • Simple Google Photos: A WordPress Plugin (23,418)

Random Read

Video Episode 4: Running, Hiking, Fishing, and Tendonitis in Telluride
These blog posts and vlog episodes feel like they're becoming rote and routine, and I'm…

Read More

Google Photo
Google Photo
Google Photo
Google Photo

Social Things

  • Family Vance
  • Texas Longhorns News

RSS From Familyvance

2025 Josheli. Donna Theme powered by WordPress